How Does Life Insurance Payout Work After Death?
A life insurance death benefit is paid only after the beneficiary files a claim, and it is frequently paid in a form other than the single check most beneficiaries expect. Insurers ordinarily offer several settlement methods, two of which leave the proceeds in the insurer's own hands while crediting the beneficiary with interest. Understanding which method has been applied determines who earns the return on the money, when the insurer's obligations end, and whether what the beneficiary received was in fact the payment the policy promised.
How Does Life Insurance Payout Work After Death?
When an insured person dies, the death benefit does not issue automatically. The named beneficiary must submit a claim, the insurer reviews it, and payment follows only after the insurer is satisfied that the claim is payable and that the claimant is entitled to receive it.
That review is ordinarily straightforward where the policy has been in force for years, the cause of death is undisputed, and one surviving beneficiary is named. It becomes considerably less straightforward where any of those conditions is absent.
When and how to claim the payout
Contact the insurer promptly after the death and request the claim forms applicable to the policy. Payment is conditioned on the submission of proof of loss, which ordinarily consists of the insurer's completed claim form together with a certified copy of the death certificate bearing a raised seal rather than a photocopy.
Additional documentation is required where the claimant is not an individual named on the policy. An estate must produce letters testamentary or letters of administration. A trustee must produce the trust instrument or a certification of trust. A guardian claiming on behalf of a minor must produce the order of appointment.
The claim is not complete, and the insurer's internal timeline does not begin, until the insurer has what it regards as a complete submission. This is the mechanism by which an otherwise routine claim becomes a delayed one: each successive request for a further document restarts the practical clock, whether or not the document requested bears on the insurer's liability.
Life insurance death benefit payout options
Insurers ordinarily make the proceeds available in one of the following forms. Which are available, and which applies by default if the beneficiary makes no election, is specified in the policy or in the plan document.
Lump sum. A single payment of the full death benefit, by check or electronic transfer.
Personal transition account. The death benefit is credited to an interest-bearing account established in the beneficiary's name, against which the beneficiary draws by means of a draft book supplied by the insurer. The insurer treats this as satisfaction of its lump-sum obligation.
Proceeds held at interest. The insurer retains the proceeds and credits interest, with the beneficiary entitled to withdraw on request, commonly subject to a minimum withdrawal amount of $100.
Annuity options. The proceeds are distributed in equal installments over a specified term or until exhausted, with interest credited on the unpaid balance.
Annuity options with life contingency. The proceeds are converted into periodic payments continuing for the beneficiary's lifetime, or for a guaranteed period, at a rate fixed when the option is elected.
Two cautions apply to the last two options. An election is frequently irrevocable once made, and the rate at which the proceeds are annuitized is set by the insurer rather than negotiated. A beneficiary who elects an installment or life income option in the weeks following a death, without reference to the policy terms or independent advice, may be unable to reverse it.
What a "personal transition account" actually is
The second and third options above warrant separate treatment, because they are the same instrument that the courts and the industry call a retained asset account, and because their legal character differs materially from what their names suggest.
The Third Circuit described the mechanism precisely. In Edmonson v. Lincoln National Life Insurance Company, the court explained that "[w]hen distributing benefits using retained asset accounts, an insurance company does not deposit any funds into the account. Rather, it merely credits the account with the benefits, and when a beneficiary writes a check on the account, the insurance company transfers funds into the account to cover the check. Until that time, the insurance company retains the money owed to the beneficiary (the 'retained assets'), and can invest the retained assets for its own profit." No. 12-1581 (3d Cir. Aug. 7, 2013).
Two consequences follow. The first is economic: the insurer credits the beneficiary with interest at a rate the insurer declares, while investing the retained funds for its own account and retaining the difference. The second is legal: the account is not a deposit account at a bank, and the funds backing it are the insurer's general account assets rather than money segregated for the beneficiary.
The Third Circuit held that the practice did not, on the facts before it, breach any fiduciary duty. "Lincoln did not breach its fiduciary duties when it exercised its discretion to pay Edmonson with a retained asset account," and "Lincoln was not acting in a fiduciary capacity when it invested the funds backing Plaintiffs' [retained asset accounts]." Id. The court further concluded that "Lincoln had completed its obligations with respect to managing or administering the plan once it established the SecureLine Account," with the result that "once Lincoln set up the SecureLine Account, the plan no longer had an interest in the assets and, under ordinary notions of property rights, Lincoln and Edmonson were in a creditor-debtor relationship." Id.
When the account is not a lawful substitute for payment
Edmonson is not the whole of the law, and the contrary authority identifies precisely when the practice is vulnerable.
In Mogel v. Unum Life Insurance Co. of America, No. 08-1334 (1st Cir. Nov. 6, 2008), the First Circuit held that the insurer had breached its fiduciary duties by establishing such accounts rather than paying the benefits. The court reasoned that the "delivery of the checkbook did not constitute a 'lump sum payment,'" that the arrangement amounted to "an IOU which did not transfer the funds to which the beneficiaries were entitled out of the plan assets," and that accordingly "UNUM remained a fiduciary with respect to those funds." It rejected the contention that the insurer's fiduciary function had been discharged, holding that "until the beneficiaries received the lump sum payments to which they were entitled, UNUM remained obligated to carry out its fiduciary duty under the plan."
The First Circuit revisited the practice in Merrimon v. Unum Life Insurance Co. of America, No. 13-2128 (1st Cir. July 2, 2014), and found no breach. It did not overrule Mogel; it distinguished it. The distinction is the operative point of this entire area, and it rested on the terms of the governing document: Mogel involved a plan whose terms required "lump sum" payment of death benefits, whereas the plan documents in Merrimon authorized payment by retained asset account.
The rule that emerges is narrower and far more useful than either holding standing alone. Whether a retained asset account constitutes payment depends on what the governing document says the beneficiary is owed. Where the policy or plan promises a lump sum and the insurer tenders a draft book, Mogel's reasoning applies directly. Where the document authorizes the account as a method of settlement, Merrimon and Edmonson control. That question is answered by the policy, the certificate of coverage, and — for employer-provided coverage — the plan document, which is why obtaining them is not a formality. An ERISA administrator is in any event obliged to act "in accordance with the documents and instruments governing" the plan. 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(D).
What a beneficiary can do about such an account
A beneficiary who receives a draft book rather than a payment is not obliged to leave the funds where they are. The account may ordinarily be closed by writing a single draft for the full balance, or by submitting a written request, and the proceeds transferred to an account of the beneficiary's own choosing.
Where a beneficiary intends to do that, there is generally little reason to delay. The rate credited on the account is declared by the insurer, and the beneficiary bears the insurer's general-account credit risk in the meantime. Funds held in such an account are not deposits at an insured depository institution, and the protections applicable to bank deposits do not apply; the applicable protection, if any, is that afforded by the state guaranty association.
How long does it take to collect a life insurance payout?
Insurers ordinarily pay an uncontested claim within 30 to 60 days of receiving a complete submission. Claims filed within the policy's contestability period, claims involving a disputed cause of death, and claims in which competing beneficiaries have come forward routinely take considerably longer.
Where payment is not made promptly, most jurisdictions require the insurer to pay interest on the death benefit, and a number impose statutory deadlines on claim handling enforceable by penalties, attorney's fees, or both. The applicable period, the rate and the remedy differ materially from state to state, and employer-provided coverage governed by ERISA is subject to a different framework in which state remedies are generally preempted.
For the full timeline, what counts as a legitimate delay and what does not, and when a delayed claim warrants legal involvement, see how long a life insurance claim takes.
Who gets the life insurance payout?
The proceeds are payable to the primary beneficiary named on the policy. If no primary beneficiary survives the insured, they pass to the named contingent beneficiary. If no designated beneficiary survives, the policy's own order-of-precedence clause governs, and in the absence of such a clause the proceeds are ordinarily payable to the estate of the insured.
That last outcome is frequently described to families as a technicality, and it is not: proceeds payable to an estate become an asset of the estate, are available to satisfy creditors' claims, and are distributed to heirs only thereafter.
For the full analysis — failed and unrecorded designations, the 120-hour survivorship rule, the statutory order of precedence for military coverage, and what happens when proceeds pass to probate — see life insurance with no named beneficiary.
Are life insurance payouts taxable?
A life insurance death benefit received by reason of the insured's death is generally excluded from the beneficiary's gross income for federal income tax purposes. Two qualifications matter in practice, and the second is a direct consequence of the settlement options described above.
Interest credited on the proceeds is ordinarily taxable as income to the beneficiary. A beneficiary who leaves the death benefit in a retained asset account, or who elects an installment or life income option, will therefore receive a portion of the distribution as taxable interest even though the underlying death benefit is not taxable.
Separately, where the proceeds are includable in the insured's gross estate, federal or state estate tax may apply at the estate level, which is a different question from the income tax treatment of the beneficiary.
This article does not constitute tax advice, and a beneficiary receiving a substantial death benefit should consult a tax professional.
What to do if the payout is delayed or denied
Obtain the policy or certificate of coverage, and — where the coverage was employer-provided — the plan document and summary plan description, and determine what method of settlement those documents actually authorize. Confirm what the insurer has characterized as payment: a credited account is not the same as a transferred sum. Read any election form before signing it, and confirm whether the election is revocable. Where a claim has been pending without a decision, put the request for a decision, and the specific items said to remain outstanding, in writing. And where the insurer has tendered a retained asset account under a policy or plan whose terms promise a lump sum, preserve the documents and obtain advice before the balance is drawn down.
If the claim has been denied, the denial letter states the insurer's position; it is not a final determination of your rights. Appeal deadlines are strict, and for employer-provided coverage governed by ERISA the administrative appeal is ordinarily the only opportunity to put evidence into the record a court will later review.
Call (888) 510-2212 to speak to a lawyer
Free Consultation
Our firm represents beneficiaries in disputes concerning the denial, delay and administration of life insurance death benefits, and has recovered millions of dollars from major insurers, including $1 million from John Hancock following a lapse declared during the insured's terminal illness, $1.1 million in settlement of a contested interpleader action, and $840,000 from an employer that failed to send a required conversion notice.
*Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Learn more: delayed life insurance claims · how long a claim takes · denied life insurance claims · ERISA claims and appeals · insurance bad faith · life insurance with no named beneficiary
